UJanet Maslin uyehla esikhundleni sakhe njengomgxeki weencwadi zemihla ngemihla kwiNew York Times ngoJulayi, ngokwememo ifunyenwe yiNkulumbuso eNew York. UNks Maslin, owayesakuba ngumgxeki kumdlalo bhanyabhanya we-Times owathatha incwadi ukubetha kwangoko, uza kuqhubeka nokuphonononga iincwadi amatyeli ambalwa ngenyanga, uxelele iCapital. Kodwa iThe Times ifuna umgxeki omtsha wencwadi yemihla ngemihla ukugcwalisa iphepha lemibhalo esemgangathweni yephepha ekwabandakanya uDwight Garner noMichiko Kakutani.
Nokuba ngaba Amaxesha uya kuqesha ngaphakathi okanye hayi yimfihlakalo. Ke, kwakhona, ezinye iingcebiso-kunye nabanye abanokuba ngabagqatswa kunye nolunye uluvo oluphoselwe kwimilinganiselo elungileyo.
Izinwele zeSeggal
Umgqatswa onokwenzeka. Usebenza kuPhononongo lweNcwadi, kulapho uDwight Garner, umgxeki wemihla ngemihla wokugqibela anyusa amanqanaba ngaphakathi kweThe Times, evela. Kwaye sele ezibonakalisile ukuba ungumvavanyi onobuchule kunye nokuqonda, engashicileli kuphela kwiXesha kodwa nakwezinye iimpapasho ezinje Incwadi nayo.
U-Alexandra Jacobs
Omnye wababhali beXesha abadlamkileyo nabonwabisayo. Okwangoku umhleli kunye nomgxeki kwiphepha leSitayile, kodwa mhlawumbi ukulungele utshintsho. Kwi-Braganca, apho wayesebenza khona ngaphambi kokuba aphulukane ne-Grey Lady, wajonga kwakhona ubufazi obuncinci bukaCondé Nast, indawo yokutyela eyenziwe nguFrank Gehry. Ukuba loo nto ayenzi imeko yamakhono akhe abalulekileyo, andazi ukuba yintoni eya kuthanda.
UGarth Risk Hallberg
Ubhale isabelo sakhe esifanelekileyo sokuphononongwa kweencwadi kwiwebhusayithi yoncwadi Izigidi kunye neXesha leNcwadi ngaphambi kokuba athengise inoveli yakhe yamaphepha angama-900 kwiKnopf malunga ne- $ 2 yezigidi kwiminyaka emibini edlulileyo. IsiXeko Somlilo imiselwe ukuba iphume ngo-Okthobha, kwaye ngaphandle kwamathandabuzo iyakubanga isiphithiphithi. Kodwa mhlawumbi ufuna igig yesiqhelo.
UMark Greif
Unjingalwazi oncedisayo kwizifundo zoncwadi kwiSikolo esitsha kunye nomhleli osisiseko we-n + 1. Incwadi yakhe entsha, Ubudala beNtlekele yoMntu , awaye wachitha iminyaka eli-10 kuyo, luphononongo olunobukrakra lwengqondo zaseMelika phakathi kwinkulungwane yama-20. Le ndoda ifundeka kakuhle.
Saeed Jones
Ungumhleli wombhalo weBuzzFeed-ayingqina ukuba ayisiyo i-oxymoron-kwaye uyimbongi. Ngaba kungonwabisa.
UMichael Robbins
Enye imbongi. Incwadi yakhe yokuqala yevesi, Umfokazi kunye nomzingeli , was… well, andilunganga ngokuchaza imibongo, yiyo loo nto ndingenguye umgxeki wencwadi. Masithi nje kwakulungile, ngendlela engaqhelekanga. Ubhale uphononongo olunengqiqo Isilayidi , Umjongi kunye neHarper, apho ahambisa khona intle Uhlalutyo yesinyithi (umculo, nangona bendimfundile kwimathiriyeli).
UMargalit Fox
Amaxesha ’ Umbhali okhokelayo. Sui injengele. Unokusibhala esihogweni aphume ekufeni, ngoku kutheni angabinakho ukubhala esihogweni ngaphandle kweencwadi?
UJohn Williams
Hayi, hayi umqambi (nangona oko kunokuba nomdla). Ukwincwadi yoPhononongo lwencwadi kunye nomnye umgqatswa onokwenzeka. Sele ebhala uphononongo kunye nodliwanondlebe nababhali-bakhe bamva nje iprofayile zikaPaul Beatty zazilunge ngokukodwa -kwaye ubhala incwadi ethi Book Review’s Open Book.
UDaniel Levin Becker
Umhleli weencwadi zeKholwa. Erudite kodwa uthobekile ngokuhlaziya ingqondo engaqhelekanga .
Katie Roiphe
Hayi, andikunyatheli apha. Ndiyazi abantu abaninzi andithandi UKatie Roiphe (nangona uDwight Garner ungumlandeli ). Kodwa yinto entle leyo. Ngaba ufuna umgxeki wencwadi oza kuba nokuqina kwaye aqikeleleke- kwaye omnye unokuphikisa ukuba yiloo nto kanye eyayinguJanet Maslin- okanye umntu oza kuthi ukumangaliswa wena?
UKathryn Schulz
Unengqondo nje enkulu. Uqinisekisile ukuba angabhala malunga noba yintoni yena ufuna , kodwa iincwadi zinethamsanqa elaneleyo lokuba kwi-bailiwick yakhe. Uye nje waya eNew Yorker evela kwiphephancwadi laseNew York, apho ndiqinisekile ukuba uyakuhlala. Kodwa amaXesha ayindawo engeyiyo, nokuba.
UmKristu uLorentzen
Uya kwiphephancwadi laseNew York kungekudala-ngaphambi kokuba abe ngumhleli kwi-London Review of Books-kodwa, uyazi, yi-Times.
A.O. UScott
Uhleli kwimiboniso bhanyabhanya yeThe Times ukusukela ngo-2000, kodwa ngaphambi koko wayengumgxeki wencwadi ngeNewsday. Ngokuqinisekileyo kufuneka ukuba udiniwe kukuchitha iintsuku zakhe kumagumbi okujonga ekhangela iifilimu ezingafaniyo. Ngaba ebengayi kuthanda ukungasebenzi iiyure kwigumbi elithe cwaka ejonge kumaphepha okubhaliweyo njengoko amaqebunga wamehlo akhe awe kwiziseko zawo? Oko kuya kuthetha ukuba, ewe, amaXesha kuya kufuneka afumane umgxeki omtsha wefilimu. Ndityumba uWesley Morris, ekufuneka naye abhale ikholamu yeendaba yeTimes. Ngelixa silapho, masinike uMichiko Kakutani ikholamu entsha, nayo ethetha: enye indawo evulekileyo yomgxeki wencwadi!