Yenza iMelika ibenkulu kwakhona nguSpider Martin, wafota ePearl, Miss, ngo-2016.Igalari yeWyatt / yeNkululeko Imisebenzi yobugcisa yoluntu inembali yokubonisa ukuba inempikiswano. Nokuba ngabantu ungayifumani , umsebenzi ngu ngendlela yabo okanye ngokungathandabuzekiyo. Kodwa kumthombo wayo yonke le micimbi yinyani elula yokuba ubugcisa ekuthethwa ngabo babufakwe kwindawo yoluntu. Awufuni ukukhetha ukubona lo msebenzi. Ikho nje, ihlala ikungcikiva ngeyayo enkulu, epinki, ifom efana nepop (umzekelo) kuhambo lwakho lwemihla ngemihla. Ngokwesiqhelo, nangona kunjalo, iziphumo ezinjalo azenziwa ngabom.
Kodwa ke kukho loo misebenzi efakiweyo ngenjongo yokuxhokonxa ingxoxo. Injalo imeko ngo-2016, xa Inkululeko, iSuper PAC eyayisandul 'ukubambela umbutho ongenzi nzuzo, yakhupha Yenza iMelika ibenkulu kwakhona I-billboard-cum-public-artwork kuHola wendlela u-80 ePearl, Nkosazana. Isilogeni sasibhangqwe ngomfanekiso ka-1965 womngcelele wamalungelo oluntu eSelma Alabama, owawuthathwe ixesha ngaphambi kokuba amajoni ombuso waseAlabama ahlasele abaqhankqalazi abamnyama — isiganeko esasiza kwaziwa NjengeCawa enegazi.
Umzobi uHank Willis Thomas, ongumsunguli wenkululeko, utshilo kudliwanondlebe neNew York Daily News ukuba inqaku lebhodibhodi yayikukuqala ingxoxo malunga nemiba efana noxinzelelo lwabavoti. Kodwa kwiinyanga ezimbalwa emva kokukhutshwa kwayo, ibhodi yezaziso yayigqunywe yiradi emnyama.
Ngenxa yokuba iPearl ithathwa njengelizwe likaTrump, abaninzi babecinga ukuba umqondiso wenziwe ngabaphathi abamhlophe. Ngelixa abanye abantu abayiqondayo injongo yomsebenzi beziva ukuba ikhuthaza ukunganyangeki, abanye bayifumanisa iloluhlobo lokuxhaphaza. UKirsten West Savali ushwankathele into abaninzi abayicingayo isiqwenga esithunyelwe Ingcambu xa wathi, Nantsi into: Inkululeko Yenza iMelika ibenkulu kwakhona Ibhilibhodi ibonakala ngathi ibangela abantu abamnyama kunokubiza abantu abamhlophe. Ukuba ukubhukuqa yeyona nto, kukusilela kum.
Ke ngekhe kumangalise ukuba kwiinzame zenkululeko zamva nje nezona zibalulekileyo, i-50 State Initiative, ibangele kwa uhlobo olunye lwempikiswano. Iphulo lobugcisa eluntwini, nelamiselwa ngoMvulo, lijolise ekumiseni iibhodi zezaziso ezifana nezo zikwiPearl kuwo onke amazwe angama-50 kunye nePuerto Rico kunye neWashington DC Iikickstarters ngaxeshanye zokubaxhasa ngezimali ngoku ziyasebenza, kwaye zidibene ziyinxalenye yento Ngokubanzi a Inyathelo lesi-1.5 sezigidi . Ingxelo iya kuthi idibanise ngaphezulu kwamaqabane endawo angama-200 kunye namagcisa ayi-175.
U-Eric Gottesman, isiseko sika-Thomas kule projekthi, uthe basebenzisa iibhodi zezaziso ngokuchanekileyo ngenxa yamandla abo oluntu ukufikelela kubaphulaphuli ngaphaya kwemida yelizwe lobugcisa: Ngokusebenzisa iibhodi zezaziso, sithatha inxaxheba kwiinkqubo-zentengiso, ubugcisa, ezopolitiko kwaye, ngokubanzi, iindlela zongxowankulu kunye nedemokhrasi — esaziyo ukuba ziyingxaki. 
Ukungavoti kuvota ngokwenene ngu-Eric Gottesman, ofote kwi-Flint, Mich., 2016.Igalari yeWyatt / yeNkululeko
Iphulo ngalinye leKickstarter linenjongo ye- $ 3,000, ngenqanaba lomvuzo elinye leedola ezili-10, ukuvala ngoJulayi 3. I-50 State Initiative ayifani nayo nayiphi na iphulo leKickstarter esiliqalisileyo, utshilo uPatton Hindle, umlawuli wezobugcisa eKickstarter, echaza ukubaleka njalo amaphulo amaninzi ngaxeshanye ayengaqhelekanga kubo kwiphulo elinye. Abazobi abathatha inxaxheba baquka uSam Durant, uGate Theaster, uMarilyn Minter kunye noCarrie Mae Weems. Ukuba Inkululeko iphumelele, iibhilibhodi ziya kumiswa ekwindla, ngokuhambelana nonyulo lwaphakathi enyakeni ngo-2018.
Kodwa yintoni eyenza ukuba le projekthi yahluke kwiiNkululeko zangaphambili kukudityaniswa kweebhodi zeebhodi ezineenkqubo zasimahla zoluntu, ezinje ngemiboniso yobugcisa kunye neentlanganiso zeholo ledolophu ekhokelwa ligcisa. Ibhodi nganye yebhodi yebhodi iya kusebenza njengesimemo, esamkela amalungu kurhulumente ngamnye ukuba athathe inxaxheba kwiincoko zasekuhlaleni-kwaye abanike indawo yokuphakamisa nayiphi na imiba abanokuba nayo kwimisebenzi elawula uhola wendlela. IZiko loLondolozo lweMbali likaFralin, umzekelo, liza kubamba iingxoxo zoluntu kunye neeseshoni zokwenza ubugcisa ukuze kufundiswe abahlali baseCharlottesville, Va. Ngembali yobukhoboka kunye nocalucalulo esixekweni. Ngokwenza njalo, Inkululeko ibambelela kwaye isebenzise eyona ntetho yobugcisa boluntu ihlala ibeka ngengozi. 
Inyathelo leMisa NguNari Ward, wafota eLexington, eKy, ngo-2016.Igalari yeWyatt / yeNkululeko
NgokukaTomas, i Yenza iMelika ibenkulu kwakhona Ibhilibhodi ayenziwanga ngolindelo lokugcina uhlobo lwempikiswano eyenzileyo. Kodwa wayenombulelo ngala mava, kuba, njengoko waxelela i-Braganca, ifundise iqela lakhe isifundo esibalulekileyo ngendlela abafuna ukuvusa ingxoxo. Ngokufanelekileyo, ukuba iibhilibhodi ngokwazo bezingonelanga.
Sibonile ukuba kukho imfuneko engxamisekileyo yeeforamu ezingakumbi zencoko yoluntu, yiyo loo nto sisebenzisana namaqabane angaphezu kwama-200 kwilizwe liphela ukwenza iiholo zedolophu kunye nemiboniso ukongeza kwiibhodi zezaziso, utshilo, Injongo yethu kukudala amathuba anamandla, anezinto ezininzi ukuze abemi bathathe inxaxheba kwiingxoxo ezimalunga ewe, imisebenzi yobugcisa yoluntu, kodwa kunye nemibuzo emikhulu abayikhuthazayo. Ngelixa isenokungabi kukujolisa kwisiphithiphithi, ubuncinci banethemba lokuba imiba ethile yamaqhosha ashushu ayakuphakanyiswa ecaleni kwemisebenzi-ingxoxo, emva kwayo yonke loo nto, ayikokuba wonke umntu uyavumelana, kwaye kukho umgca olungileyo phakathi kwengxoxo kunye nembambano.
Yintoni enokukunceda kwinkululeko ukuba icace ngakumbi ngeli xesha kukutshintsha kwayo ukusuka kwiSuper PAC (ikomiti yamanyathelo ezopolitiko azimeleyo anokunyusa imali engenamda) iye kwinto engenzi nzuzo. Inkululeko ayikaze ihambelane neqela lezopolitiko, kodwa iiSuper Pacs zihlala zisenza njalo. Kudliwanondlebe ne-Art Newspaper , UGottesman wathi imbonakalo yezopolitiko enxulunyaniswa ne-Super Pac yayinzima kakhulu kumaziko athile ukuba asizise, nangona babenomdla kumbono wobugcisa.
Kwijelo ngalinye lomkhankaso weKickstarter, ingxelo yokugqibela ifundeka ngolu hlobo, Omnye wemiceli mingeni onomdla kakhulu kukuqinisekisa ukuba iibhodi zethu zezaziso ziqondwa ziinkampani ezinkulu zosasazo njengemisebenzi yobugcisa, kwaye ingeyonxalenye yalo naliphi na iphulo lezopolitiko. 
Sikhusele kwiMetadata yethu NguTrevor Paglen, wafota eDenver, ngo-2016.Igalari yeWyatt / yeNkululeko
I-50 State Initiative ibonisa umdla onomdla phakathi kwengingqi kunye nelizwe. Isenokuba yeyona ntsebenziswano inkulu yoyilo kwimbali yase-US, kodwa akukho nto iyondeleleneyo ngayo. Kanye njengoko iibhilibhodi ziya kwahluka kwilizwe liphela, kuya kuba njalo kwiincoko eziveliswa ngabo. Akukho siqinisekiso sokunxibelelana phakathi korhulumente, kwaye akukho siqinisekiso sokuba iibhilibhodi ziya kunyuka konke konke. Ngamaphulo angama-52 ahlukeneyo, amalungu kurhulumente ngamnye anikwe uxanduva lokuxhasa ngezimali ibhodi yezemali, kodwa banokugcina umkhondo kunye nokunceda amanye amazwe. Umbuzo, nangona kunjalo, ngowokuba okanye hayi amazwe aya kuziva enyanzelekile ukuba azibandakanye kulo msebenzi wobambiswano.
Kodwa kuTomas noGottesman, kuncinci malunga nokudibanisa kunye nokunye malunga ne-nuance. Umbono kukuba sizama ukwenza uluhlu lweencoko ezisemthethweni kodwa ezinxibeleleneyo ezingasasebenziyo kwaye ezifanelekileyo kubantu, utshilo uGottesman, kudliwanondlebe noMiami New Times . Kwaye oku kungumongo wento yobugcisa ngokwabo. Yini i Yenza iMelika ibenkulu kwakhona Ibhilibhodi ebonakalisiweyo yayiluhlobo lokungaqondakali oluzibolekisa kumathuba angenasiphelo.
