Eyona Itv Yimalini 'iMidlalo yeTrone' ephefumlelwe ziiMfazwe zoBomi bokwenyani? Ingcali Ilinganisa.

Yimalini 'iMidlalo yeTrone' ephefumlelwe ziiMfazwe zoBomi bokwenyani? Ingcali Ilinganisa.

Yeyiphi Imovie Ukubona?
 
Kanye kanye inyani kangakanani na Imidlalo yeethrone ?UHelen Sloane / HBO



Ixesha lokugqibela le-HBO Imidlalo yeethrone Inkulumbuso ngeCawa, phantse iminyaka emibini emva kwesiphelo seXesha lesi-7. Ngelo xesha, senze isabelo sethu esifanelekileyo sokuqikelela ukuba olona luhlu lukhulu lwethelevishini luya kuphela njani. Kodwa ngelixa siqinisekile kakhulu kuthi izakhono zakho zokucinga kunye nokucinga , Akungabazeki ukuba ingcali iya kuzisa ukuqonda ngakumbi kwitafile kuneReditor yakho ephakathi.

Ngena uBarry Strauss, unjingalwazi wembali kunye nezakudala kwiYunivesithi yaseCornell kunye nombhali OoKesare abalishumi , ebalisa ibali leenkulungwane ezintathu ezinesiqingatha zoBukhosi baseRoma kubomi babali-10 babo babalawuli ababalulekileyo. Nangona Imidlalo yeethrone wehla ngeedragons kunye ne-zombies ze-ice, uya kuba ngowokuqala ukukuxelela ukuba isendele nzulu kubomi bokwenyani. Ngapha koko, uthi ngokujonga iziganeko ezikhuthazayo Ingoma ye-Ice noMlilo umbhali uGeorge RR Martin kwaye Ababonisi uDavid Benioff kunye no-D. Weiss, singakwazi ukudibanisa kunye indlela echanekileyo eya kumgca wokugqibela weSizini 8.

Rhuma kwiNcwadana yeendaba yoMbonisi

AmaXesha Aphakathi ayenogonyamelo, inkolo, ubukhosi kunye nohlelo— Imidlalo yeethrone Ngokuqinisekileyo ulungile, uStrauss uxelele uMbonisi. AmaXesha aPhakathi nawo abonisa iinqaba, inkqubo ye-feudal, iitumente ezi-chivalrous kunye nehlabathi lokunyaniseka.

NgokukaStrauss, Imidlalo yeethrone inokulandelela imvelaphi yayo ukubuyela kwilitha lamaxesha aphambili, ngakumbi iMfazwe yesiNgesi yeRos (1455-1485), ukuwa kweRoma (476 CE) kunye nokubulawa kwabantu eGlencoe (1692). Ngaphaya koko, iimbali zentsomi impucuko, inkcubeko kunye nabalinganiswa baxelelwa ngembali erekhodiweyo.

UMartin kunye nababonisi baphosa umnatha wabo ngokubanzi xa kuziwa kwimpembelelo yezembali, utshilo. Basebenzisa uMlilo waseGrisi, isixhobo esifihlakeleyo esisetyenziswa ngumkhosi wasemanzini waseByzantium; I-sagas yaseIceland; ‘Abezinye iintlanga’ abahlaseli beentlobo ezahlukahlukeneyo — ngokusisiseko, amajoni akhwele amahashe asuka emathafeni, anjengeeHuns okanye iiMongol; imikhosi yamaRoma kunye nephalanx yamaGrike; AmaAmazon kunye namagorha amabhinqa anjengoBrienne waseTarth; ubukhosi bamandulo; kunye ne-Italiya Renaissance, kunye nozwilakhe wenkolo u-Savonarola waseFlorence bekhumbula u-Sparrow oPhakamileyo.

Ewe ewe GoT Ngokucacileyo ii-dudes zinencasa ye-eclectic. Kodwa kuthekani ngesiphumo sokugqibela kuthotho? Ixesha lesi-8 ngokucacileyo liyakuthatha iphepha-mvume lokuyila elokuzisa esona sigqibo silungileyo ngokwembono ebalisayo, kodwa ngokudibanisa imizekelo yokwenyani yobomi kunye nokuthanda kwakhe ngokungagungqiyo, uStrauss uye weza noqikelelo lokugqibela lokulindelwa kokugqibela.

UKumkani wasebusuku uza koyiswa: intsomi yakudala ayinakuvumela ububi ukuba boyise, utshilo uStrauss. Ayizukuba lula, nangona kunjalo. Devito Yayisisithethe samandulo saseRoma apho injengele yayincama ubomi bayo edabini ukuze izuze uothixo ukuze iphumelele umkhosi wayo. Inkqubo ye- devito NguDecius Mus jikelele emfazweni e-Itali ngo-340 BC washiya uphawu olukhulu kwimemori yaseRoma. Unoko engqondweni, ukuze uKumkani woBusuku oyiswe, lindela umlinganiswa ophambili ukuba azincame. UJon Snow? UDany? Zombini?

Nangona uStrauss ebona ukunqotshwa koKumkani woBusuku kwixesha elizayo, ukuphumelela kuye kuya kuza ngendleko. Uhlela iidragons zikaDany njengezixhobo zoyikiso ngokuhambelana neendlovu zemfazwe zikaHannibal Barca. UHannibal wayengumlawuli wamasosha owoyikwayo nowoyikekayo ovela eCarthage yamandulo owazisa iindlovu zaseAfrika kule mihla i-Itali ngexesha lokuhlasela kwakhe iRoma. Ngelixa zibonakalise zizixhobo ezisebenzayo zemfazwe, ukusilela kokugqibela kukaHannibal kuphakamisa ukuba iidragons zinokutshatyalaliswa, ezinokulunga Iitrone ebalisayo.

Nangona kunjalo, ngelixa uninzi lweWesteros lunokunyuka ngomsi (umkhenkce?) Ngoku njengokuba iWhite Walkers yagqabhuka kuDonga kwisiphelo seXesha lesi-7, sinobungqina obaneleyo bokuba ubomi buya kuqhubeka.

Eyothusayo njengoko injalo le, imbali yaseRoma isixelela ukuba abantu baseWesteros akufuneki boyike, utshilo uStrauss. Ukutyhubela iinkulungwane, iiGalls, amaTeuton, amaParti, iMarcomanni, kunye neBritani, phakathi kwabanye, beza begaleleka kwimida, kodwa amaRoma abuya nayo. Ewe, ekugqibeleni, ubukhosi bawa, kodwa kuphela eNtshona kwaye kuphela emva kweminyaka engama-700. Ubukhosi baseRoma eMpuma baqhubeka bukho.

Kodwa xa umsi uphelile, ngubani oza kulawula inkunkuma kwaye akhokele ubukumkani kwinkqubo yokwakha kwakhona? UStrauss ucinga ukuba uBukhosi baseRoma busifundisa ukuba abalawuli abalungileyo banqabile, ababi baqhelekile kwaye oozwilakhe banamandla kakhulu. Nangona kunjalo, ngelixa ithemba lobukhosi obugqithisileyo obufana nengcinezelo uCersei Lannister -okanye, okona kubi, uKumkani woBusuku bohlanga-luza kuqhuba ixesha lokugqibela, kodwa ukholelwa ukuba isidima sizakoyisa.

Ekugqibeleni, utshilo uStrauss, ngokuqinisekileyo abantu baya kukhetha inkokheli elungileyo [uMlawuli waseRoma] uMarcus Aurelius. Iminwe iqhiniwe.

Amanqaku Onokuthanda :