UHillary Clinton uthetha nabaxhasi kwi-International Brotherhood ye-Electric Workers Hall ngoLwesibini, nge-14 kaJuni, ePittsburgh, ePennsylvania.(Ifoto nguJeff Swensen / imifanekiso kaFetty) Ngequbuliso izinto zazilungelelane ngokugqibeleleyo kuHillary Clinton kwiphulo lakhe lobongameli. Emva kweenyanga zokungakwazi ukuhlazisa uSenator uBernie Sanders, usoshiyali oneminyaka engama-74 omele ilizwe elinesibini nje kwishumi ekhulwini labemi baseMelika, walisonga iqela lakhe lokutyumba iWhite House. Indibano yeDemokhrasi ePhiladelphia kwinyanga ezayo izakuba yinto esesikweni, nokuba uBernie Bros ungxame kangakanani kwiinyawo zakhe.
Ukuthimba olo loyiso kwiveki ephelileyo, uMongameli u-Obama uvumile u-Hillary Clinton njengonyulo lweqela labo ngo-2016. Ngeli xesha, nayo yayisesikweni, kuba uMnu. ekugqibeleni Ukuyomxhasa-nokuba igazi elibi lihlala kangakanani phakathi kwabo kukhuphiswano luka-2008-yayiyanelisa abaxhasi bakhe, ukuba mhlawumbi begqithile.
Ukuncoma kukamongameli uvavanyo lukaClinton, kubandakanya Andiqondi ukuba wakhe wabakho umntu ofaneleke kangaka ukubamba le ofisi, kufuneka ahambe indlela ende ekumanyaniseni iqela labo njengoko ejongene nomchasi wakhe weRiphabhlikhi, mhlawumbi uDonald Trump, kule ekwindla.
Ukunconywa kuka-Obama yayikukuthomalalisa amanxeba asandula ukubulawa nguClinton ezandleni zeSebe likaRhulumente kwi-imeyile yeGate. Ingxelo ekudala ilindelwe yiOfisi yoMhloli Jikelele eFoggy Bottom inokuthiwa iyabetha kwaye, njengokoNdivavanye kule kholamu, ishiya ngaphandle kwamathandabuzo ukuba uHillary Clinton ucwangcise umgaqo wemithetho kunye nemigaqo ekugcinweni kweerekhodi ze-Federal kunye nokuphathwa kolwazi oluhleliweyo.
Okubi kakhulu, ingxelo ye-IG ishiya ngaphandle kwamathandabuzo ukuba uClinton uxokile kakhulu malunga ne-imeyileGate ukusukela ngela xesha isaphulelo sagqabhuka ngaphezulu konyaka ophelileyo. Ukusukela ukuba iSebe likaRhulumente, elalikhokelwa nguClinton ngethuba lekota yokuqala kaMongameli u-Obama, alinakho ukupeyintwa ngokucacileyo njengenxalenye yeQhinga lePhiko laseLungelo eliKhulu eliye labonwa liQela uClinton lisithele ngasemva kwawo onke amaqhekeza eendaba amabi, le ngxelo ibangele umonakalo wokwenyani kwiphulo lika-Hillary lobongameli.
Kuyinyani kwifom, waqala waziphinda ngamanqindi kwaye wenza amanye amapolisa. Inqaku labo eliphambili lokuthetha-ukuba i-imeyileGate ihlala iyinto engekhoyo, into ethandabuzekayo kwingcinga yeFoxNews ngaphezulu kwebali eliyinyani-iyaqhubeka nokuthengiswa mihla le. Njengoko yena ngokuzithemba watsho kwiikhamera kwiveki ephelileyo, akukho thuba lokuba abekw 'ityala nge-imeyile yeGate, nokuba ithini i-FBI kuphando lwayo olusebenzayo.
Sukuyenza impazamo, kukho ngaphezulu kwamagosa aphezulu kwezobuntlola athe gca malunga nokungayikhathaleli ngabom imithetho kaHillary Clinton.
Ngomlinganiso olungileyo, uClinton uxelele ixesha leshumi elinanye, akukho nto ndiyithumeleyo okanye ndiyifumeneyo ngelo xesha ephawulwe yahlelwa. Le dodge iqeshwe unyaka njengeqweqwe liQela uClinton ukuchaza ukuba ulwazi oluchongiweyo lukhulu kangakanani, kubandakanya ubuncinci ishumi elinambini leimeyile ezichazwe kwimfihlo ephezulu okanye ngaphezulu, phakathi kwazo iinkqubo zokufikelela ezikhethekileyo ezibuthathaka kuzo zombini INC kwaye NSA , Inxeba kwi-imeyile kaClinton yangasese engacaciswanga.
Nawuphi na umntu obuzayo uya kufuna ukwazi Njani UHillary Clinton uqinisekile ukuba akanakubekwa tyala nge-imeyile, kuba uphando lwe-FBI luhlala luvulekile. Ngokufanayo, kufanelekile ukubuzwa ukuba kutheni u-Obama evakalelwa kufanelekile ukuxhasa uClinton ukuba aphumelele kwi-White House ngelixa i-FBI iqhubeka nokumphanda, kuba nakuphi na ukuhanjiswa kwe-Bureau kulo mbandela kuya kuphelela kwidesika yegqwetha jikelele, uLoretta Lynch -Osebenzela uMongameli u-Obama. INdlu yeNdlu uyanyanzelisa ayisiyiyo le ndlela yokungcolisa ityala. Nangona kunjalo, kuba u-Obama ligqwetha lomgaqo-siseko ngemvelaphi, akanako ukusilela ukubona ukuba oku kudala njani ungquzulwano olukhulu lomdla.
Ngaphezulu koko, ukuphuma kukaClinton akusebenzi. A uphando olutsha ibonisa ukuba iipesenti ezingama-60 zabavoti bacinga ukuba uyaxoka malunga nee-imeyile zakhe, xa kuthelekiswa neepesenti ezingama-27 ezikholelwayo kuye. Nangona esenomphetho wokuvota, i-imeyile yeGate ihlala iyingxaki enkulu kwiphulo likaHillary, kuba ibalaselisa uninzi lwabantu baseClintonian abantu abaninzi baseMelika abangabathandiyo ixesha elide. Ukuxhaphaka, okucwangciswe ngocoselelo. Ubuxoki bokufihla urhwaphilizo kunye nokucima inkqubo yethu yezopolitiko. Ngaphezulu kwako konke, ukuqonda okunzulu ukuba imigaqo yeyabemi abaqhelekileyo, hayi iClintons kunye necoterie yabo eyilungelo.
Ukanti enye indlela yokudibana kukaClinton ubuxoki, urhwaphilizo, kunye neemfihlo kuye kwavela umbulelo kwi-imeyile yeGate. Oku kubandakanya ukubonakala kuka-Rajiv K. Fernando ngo-2011 kwiBhodi yeeNgcebiso ngezoKhuseleko yaMazwe ngaMazwe, ikomiti e-ethe-ethe ejongene nomsebenzi weSebe likaRhulumente kwimicimbi yokulwa nokwanda kunye nemicimbi yenyukliya. Inkqubo ye- ISAB Ubona uninzi lobukrelekrele obuchongwe kakhulu kwaye buqulathe iingcali ezinamava kulawulo lweengalo nakukhuseleko lwamazwe aphesheya. Yayo amalungu ikakhulu ziigreybeard ezinamava eminyaka kwezomkhosi, idiplomacy, kunye nokhuseleko.
UFernando wayengekho kwezo zinto. Umthengisi wezorhwebo waseChicago ongenamvelaphi efanelekileyo, amalungu e-ISAB abonakala edidekile kukubonakala kwakhe phakathi kwabo ngo-2011. Besingazi ukuba ungubani, latsho elinye ilungu lebhodi. UFernando wayengazi nto ngobukrelekrele okanye izixhobo zenyukliya, kodwa wayengumxhasi weligi enkulu kwiClinton Foundation-kwaye lonto yayiyinto ebalulekileyo. Nangona iQela uClinton liye lenza iinzame zokufihla ukuba uFernando ufike njani kwi-ISAB- ngakumbi indlela abasebenzi bakaHillary Clinton abambeke ngayo ngobuqhophololo ebhodini- le yayisesinye isiqwenga sokudlala esenziwa kuRhulumente wase-US kunye nomhlawuli werhafu ngabakwaClintons .
Eyona nto imbi kakhulu kuHillary kutshanje kuvele ukuba ubuncinci enye ye-imeyile ayinikezele kubaphenyi phantsi kwesamani uyenzile Inolwazi oluhleliweyo olwaphawulwa ngolo hlobo. Epreli 2012 ikhonkco le-imeyile ixoxa ngomnxeba ozayo nomongameli omtsha waseMalawi. Inxalenye ebalulekileyo yi-imeyile evela kuMonica Hanley, umncedisi, kuClinton, kubandakanya iphepha lokufowuna likanobhala. Ngokwemigaqo, lo wayeyinqaku likaNobhala uClinton emxelela into ekufuneka eyixoxe ngexesha lengxoxo yakhe ecwangcisiweyo kunye nentloko yelinye ilizwe.
Asazi ukuba yayiyintoni, nangona kunjalo, kuba uninzi lwe-imeyile luye lwacwangciswa njengoko luhlelwe kwinqanaba leNgcaciso, elona nqanaba lisezantsi kuRhulumente wase-US. Umpu wokutshaya apha kukuba iphepha lokutsalela umnxeba liqala ngomnxeba: (C) Injongo yomnxeba: Ukuthuthuzela uMongameli uMutharika odlulayo kunye nokuvuyisana noMongameli uBanda ngokufunga kwakhe kutshanje.
Yonke into emva koko yenziwe kwakhona. Kodwa leyo (C) yinto ebizwa ngokuba yinxalenye yokumakisha, ukucebisa umfundi ukuba umhlathi olandelayo uhlelwe. (Kuba yonke le nto isebenza kanjani, yabona lo uchazayo Ngamanye amagama, uHanley wayesazi ukuba uthumela ulwazi oluhleliweyo kwi-imeyile engachazwanga kwiakhawunti ye-imeyile kaHillary Clinton, ukwaphula umthetho wase-Federal ngokungathandabuzekiyo.
Kunzima ukubona indlela i-FBI enokukuhoya ngayo ukwaphulwa komthetho okucacileyo.
Oku kunika ubuxoki kwimantra ephindaphindiweyo kaClinton engazange ayithumele okanye ithunyelwe nantoni na kuphawulwe okuhleliweyo kwi-imeyile yakhe engacaciswanga, nge-imeyile ngelixa wayesebenza njengoonozakuzaku belizwe lethu. Oko kububuxoki, siyazi ngoku.
Ngokwenyani, akukho mntu uya entolongweni ngenxa yokuphatha gwenxa ulwazi oluhleliweyo kwinqanaba eliyimfihlo. Nangona kunjalo, i-imeyile kaHanley iyangqina ukuba abasebenzi bakaHillary babethumela nge-imeyile ulwazi oluhlelweyo kumajelo angafakwanga, ukuba lalibhalwe lahlulwa, kwaye lalidlulisa iserver ye-imeyile yobuqu kaClinton. Kunzima ukukholelwa ukuba umncedisi nje ofana noMonica Hanley uthathe isigqibo sokwaphula umthetho ngolu hlobo, njengoko wayeqinisekile ukuba wayeyiyo, ngokuzenzela kwakhe.
Kwakhona kunzima ukubona indlela i-FBI enokukuhoya ngayo ukwaphulwa komthetho okucacileyo. Ikwaphakamisa imibuzo malunga nento eyayikwi-imeyile ezingama-30,000 uClinton wagqiba kwelokuba azicime. Phantse kwiinyanga ezintlanu eziseleyo kude kube lunyulo lobongameli, sinokulindela isigubhu esiqhelekileyo sesityhilelo malunga ne-imeyile yeGate, akukho namnye kubo oncoma umtyunjwa weDemokhrasi.
Kwiveki ephelileyo i-Associated Press yaqhekeka ibali elikhulu malunga nendlela ii-imeyile ezingacaciswanga zikaClinton ezibandakanya ngayo amagama ayinyani abasebenzi beCIA abakhonza phesheya kolwandle ngokufihlakeleyo. Ezi yayingezizo iindaba, eneneni ndaliqhekeza ibali elifanayo kwiinyanga ezine ezidlulileyo kule kholamu . Nangona kunjalo, iakhawunti ye-AP yongeza iinkcukacha kwinto eyenziwa nguClinton kunye nabasebenzi bakhe, iintshukumo ezibeke ubomi babasebenzi baseCIA emngciphekweni. Isenokuba kukwaphula umthetho UMthetho oKhusela iZazisi , Umthetho wowe-1982 owawubalasele kwisikrelemnqa esiphakathi e-CIA esingqonge igosa le-CIA uValerie Plame, nelithande amajelo eendaba aphambili. Kutshanje, igosa langaphambili leCIA UJohn Kiriakou uchithe iminyaka emibini kwintolongo yase-Federal ngokwaphula lo mthetho.
Ukwenza izinto zibe mbi ngakumbi kwiQela uClinton, kwiveki ephelileyo kwavela ukuba uninzi lwee-imeyile ezichaziweyo eziphantsi kophando zazibandakanya iingxoxo malunga nogwayimbo lwe-CIA oluzayo ePakistan. Abancedisi bakaClinton babenononophelo ukunqanda amagama anamaqhosha ashushu njenge-CIA kunye ne-drone kwezi imeyile ezingachazwanga, ukuzibandakanya kwisiko apho iintlola zihlala zithetha ngomba.
Nangona kunjalo, inyani ebalulekileyo kukuba i-CIA-enezwi apha-ithatha olu lwazi njengeMfihlo ePhambili, kwaye inovakalelo olukhulu. Kwakungenalo ishishini lokuba kwi-imeyile engachazwanga yomntu. Njengonobhala welizwe, uNksz Clinton kunye nabasebenzi bakhe abaphezulu babe nokufikelela kwiinkqubo zonxibelelwano ezihleliweyo iiyure ezingama-24 ngosuku. Bakhethe ukungazisebenzisi apha-ukhetho olwaphula ngokucacileyo umthetho we-Federal. Ngaphaya koko, le ngxelo intsha ibonisa ukuba ingxoxo yangaphambili ye-Clintonian EmailGate yangaphambili, yokuba iingxoxo zeedrones ezikwi-imeyile zazingaphaya kokuncamathisela amaqhekeza eendaba, kwaye ke ngenxa yoko amsulwa, yayilelinye ubuxoki obunobuso obunempandla.
I-FBI inokujonga njani konke oku kwaye ingacebisi ukutshutshiswa komntu kwinto ethile kwi-imeyile yeGate. Ukanti uMongameli u-Obama ubonakalise ngokucacileyo ukuba ayisiyonto inkulu. UMlawuli uJames Comey unomsebenzi onzima phambi kwakhe xa ethatha izindululo ezisemthethweni ze-FBI ngokubhekisele kwi-EmailGate kwiGqwetha eliyiNtloko likaLynch ukuze enze isenzo, mhlawumbi ngamanye amaxesha kweli hlobo. Kuba u-Comey ngoku uphantsi kwelifu ngaphezulu kwe-FBI'sukuphatha kakubika-Omar Mateen, umbulali we-jihadist wase-Orlando, mhlawumbi ukurhoxa kwakhe malunga naloo nto kuya kwamkeleka kwiNdlu yeWhite House, eya kuthi emva koko ifumane umlawuli omtsha ozimisele ngakumbi ukugoba kwiminqweno ka-Obama.
Sukuyenza impazamo, kukho ngaphezulu kwamagosa aphezulu kwezobuntlola eWashington, DC, acace gca malunga nokungahoyi ngabom kukaHillary Clinton imithetho echazwe ngokucacileyo ekusingatheni ulwazi oluhleliweyo. Ukuziphatha kwakhe gwenxa kubeka emngciphekweni iinkqubo ezinobukrelekrele-kunye nobomi. Nokuba u-Comey uyimvu yedini apha, kukho iintlola ezikwinqanaba eliphezulu ezikulungeleyo ukuvuza iinkcukacha ezikhohlakeleyo ze-EmailGate kumajelo eendaba ukuba umongameli utsala uDick Nixon kwaye uzama ukuphazamisa umGaqo-siseko wethu ukuze azikhusele kunye nalowo uza kungena ezihlangwini zakhe.
Kwaye kwisiganeko esingalindelekanga sokuba kungabikho mntu kwikomkhulu lesizwe sethu ozimiseleyo ukuya esidlangalaleni ngento kanye eyenziwe nguHillary Clinton, ngoku kubonakala ngathi amaRussia angenza njalo. Nguwoiyavakala kakhuluukuba iinkonzo zobukrelekrele zaseRussia, phakathi kwezinye, zininzi ii-imeyile zikaClinton, mhlawumbi zonke, zinikezwe indlela ebuthathaka ngayo amalungiselelo okhuseleko.
Ke ngoko i ingxelo yangoku NguJulian Assange, intloko yeWikileaks, ukuba umbutho wakhe uceba ukukhupha ii-imeyile ezingaphezulu zikaClinton akufuneki zikhutshwe ngaphandle kwesandla. Nangona u-Assange ethambekele kwiinqwelomoya ezinqabileyo, iWikileaks kudala isebenza njenge umphambili wobukrelekrele baseRussia , njengoko iinkonzo zokhuselo zaseNtshona zisazi kakuhle, kungangokuba yinto entle ukuba angazifumana ezinye ii-imeyile zikaHillary. Ingayimpoxo enkulu ukuba iKremlin itshabalalisa iminqweno kamongameli uHillary Clinton ngenxa yokungahoyi kwakhe ezokhuseleko kwezonxibelelwano xa wayengunobhala welizwe.
UJohn Schindler yingcali yezokhuseleko kunye nowayesakuba ngumhlalutyi weArhente yoKhuseleko kuZwelonke kunye negosa lobukrelekrele. Ingcali kwezobuntlola kunye nobunqolobi, ukwaligosa lomkhosi wamanzi kunye nenjingalwazi yeWar College. Upapashe iincwadi ezine kwaye uku-Twitter ku @ 20committee.
